Inkscape vs Illustrator vs. CorelDraw

Inkscape VS Illustrator VS CorelDraw | 2019 Comparison

Inkscape VS Illustrator VS CorelDraw | 2019 Comparison 1024 602 Nick Saporito

When it comes to vector design, the big three applications are Inkscape, Illustrator, and CorelDraw. All three are excellent options and are completely capable of handling raw design needs, but the one that you should use depends on you and your own personal needs. In today’s post I’ll be comparing Inkscape vs Illustrator vs CorelDraw — both the pros and cons of each — so you can decide for yourself.

Inkscape

Inkscape screenshot

Inkscape is an open source vectors graphics application available for all major operating systems, and it has been my preferred vector graphics tool since I started back in 2012. Don’t let the fact that it’s free fool you into thinking of it as anything less than professional. This isn’t MS Paint. Inkscape is capable of virtually anything any other vector design software is capable of from a design standpoint. 

Pros

✅ Cost: It’s hard to beat free. Inkscape is a great option if you’re just starting out and have no money to invest.

✅ Less CPU Demands: Inkscape is a very lightweight application that will run good enough on low-end computers with outdated hardware.

✅ Intuitiveness: This is just my own opinion, but Inkscape’s UI and functionality seem slightly more intuitive than Illustrator’s. A good example of this would be editing gradients on the canvas. It just functions in a more natural way in Inkscape.

✅ Versatility: Works on all operating systems, including Linux. In fact, it runs best on Linux in my experience.

✅ Community: Inkscape is made by volunteers who are passionate about their work and put principles and values over profit. This makes for a supportive grass roots community that feels good to be a part of. 

Cons

❌ Lack of CMYK Support: No ability to output files in a CMYK color format, making Inkscape not a very good choice for designing anything needing to be printed.

❌ Instability: You’ll regularly experience bugs and glitches.

❌ Cross Platform: Since Adobe is the industry standard, Adobe’s proprietary formats tend to be what’s most commonly used by designers and clients. This can pose a problem when someone else wants to send you an Adobe file for you to work on.

❌ Employment: Hardly used by any design studios or agencies, meaning your Inkscape skills probably won’t land you a traditional job.

Who should learn Inkscape?

  • An aspiring freelancer who has no immediate plans to seek traditional employment at a design studio or agency.
  • Online business owners (bloggers, Instagram influencers, YouTubers, Amazaon sellers, etc.) whose focus is not design, but may occasionally need simple DIY graphics to supplement their work.
  • Anyone using a low-end computer that would struggle with more comprehensive applications like Illustrator.
  • Anyone who deals primarily with digital design and will not need to design for print.

Adobe Illustrator

Adobe Illustrator

Illustrator is a vector graphics application by Adobe. It is widely recognized as the industry standard tool for vector design and is used by the overwhelming majority of studios, agencies, and professional designers. 

Pros

✅ Employment Opportunities: Since Illustrator is the industry standard for vector design, there’s more upside to learning it over any other vector application. It’s what most employers and institutions use. Knowing how to use the Adobe software will put you in a great position to qualify for employment as a graphic designer.

✅ Extensive Features: Although Illustrator doesn’t do anything that the other vector tools can’t also do, it does have some neat features that can automate some of your work and save time that would otherwise be spent doing it manually. A good example of this would be working with multiple art boards — something I always wished Inkscape had. 

✅ Development: Since Adobe is the industry leader, innovative new features and tools tend to debut on Illustrator before they eventually make their way over to the alternatives.

✅ Proprietary Formats: Adobe’s proprietary formats (.ai, .psd, etc.) tend to be what’s most commonly used by designers and requested by clients. Although there’s workarounds for opening and creating Illustrator files with Inkscape, it’s far from perfect because things sometimes get lost in translation. Having access to Adobe software means you’ll be able to work with proprietary files other designers and clients send you without a problem.

✅ Cross Platform Usability: One thing I love about the Adobe suite is how well all of its applications communicate with each other. Vector graphics created with Illustrator can very easily be imported into After Effects, Premiere Pro, Photoshop, etc. and worked with further. 

Cons

❌ Price: Adobe software is sold as a service, meaning it’s an ongoing monthly expense. That’s a pretty big pill to swallow if design isn’t a big part of your job or business and you just need occasional graphics.

❌ Hardware Requirements: Requires high performance hardware in order to run well. As I wrote about recently, using Adobe software on a low-end machine is very frustrating. Not only will you need to fork over some dough for the software, but you’ll need to invest in a high performance machine as well.

❌ No Linux support: If you want to use the Adobe suite, you’ll have to do so on Windows or Mac.

Who should learn Illustrator?

  • Anyone who wishes to be employed as a graphic designer at a design studio or agency.
  • Students (Adobe gives discounts to students.)
  • Aspiring freelancers who have money to invest in software and high performance hardware.

CorelDraw

CorelDraw screenshot

CorelDraw is a vectors graphics application by the Corel Corporation. Although I have little experience working with it, it does seem to be a nice middle-of-the-road option. 

Pros

✅ Price: Although the CorelDraw suite comes with quite a substantial upfront cost (see current prices here,) it eventually becomes a better value than Adobe Creative Cloud if you use it long enough, because you only have to pay for it once and you own it for life (they do offer a subscription plan if you’d prefer that though.)

✅ CMYK Output: Unlike Inkscape, CorelDraw allows you to create print-ready files in CMYK format like Illustrator does, but without its price tag.

✅ Design at Scale: According to some print shop owners I’ve talked to, they tend to prefer CorelDraw because apparently it has a much larger canvas than Illustrator, meaning you can design large signs and banners at scale. 

✅ Employment Opportunities: In my experience CorelDraw is the preferred application used by most sign shops, so becoming proficient with it can help land you a job at a local sign shop.

Cons

❌ Employment Opportunities: Yes, this is both a pro and a con. Knowing how to use CorelDraw will qualify you to work at sign shops and the like, but that’s about it. Most everyone else demands proficiency with the Adobe suite.

❌ Windows Only: According to Corel’s website, CorelDraw is currently not on its list of Mac-compatible applications. This is the kiss of death for their hopes of ever taking significant market share from Adobe in my opinion because most creatives prefer Mac.

❌ Cross Platform: Much like Inkscape, you’ll have trouble working with Adobe’s proprietary formats.

Who should learn CorelDraw?

  • Anyone who will work primarily with print and/or would potentially like to work at a sign shop.
  • An aspiring freelancer who has some money to invest but would prefer something a little more economical than Illustrator to keep monthly expenses low.

Learn To Master The Software

Gain a complete understanding of your favorite design apps with my comprehensive collection of video courses. Each course grants access to our private community where you can ask questions and get help when needed.

  81 Videos
  11 Modules

The Inkscape Master Class

Tutorials, quizzes and practice exercises for learning every tool & feature in Inkscape.

Price: $17
  82 Videos
  10 Modules

The Affinity V3 Master Class

Tutorials, quizzes and practice exercises for learning every tool & feature in Affinity.

Price: $22
  98 Videos
  7 Modules

Illustrator Master Class

Tutorials, quizzes and practice exercises for learning every tool & feature in Illustrator.

Price: $17
  70 Videos
  9 Modules

GIMP Master Class

Learn how to use all of the primary tools and features in the GIMP application.

Price: $17

View All Courses

Nick Saporito

Hi, I'm Nick— a Philadelphia-based graphic designer with over 10 years of experience. Each year millions of users learn how to use design software to express their creativity using my tutorials here and on YouTube.

All stories by: Nick Saporito
38 comments
  • Commonsense

    Regarding Inkscape, i’ll say the Instability part is not that much bad as one will think of. Also it do save a version of the file just before the crash and you could recover it from there if you’re not saving the file at regular interval.

    About the cross platform inability, i would say the latest variant can open adobe files even though it cannot save back in adobe. The major cross platform isssue related to Inkscape is its inablity to save the file in plain svg but their own kinda properitory format of Inkscape svg which is worthless if you want to load the same in any other editing software. If they can come out with making plain svg as the default this can be overcome. But the ego of some of the designers and the lack of foresight within the team is holding Inkscape back from achieving it’s full potential of cross platform adaptability.

  • Shamanu

    Working with CorelDraw for 12 years by now. The support for Mac and the web app are such big pluses for them. You basically can do anything with corel. Like everything: logos, flyers, signage, website templates, anything the clients need. No client cares if it’s made with Illustrator or Inkscape or any oither software.
    But CorelDraw is a great tools, if you learn to use it at the right potential. It’s easy, it works great with macros and you have a lot of extensions.

    • Stephan

      After using CoreldRAW for over 22 years now, I can confirm, you can do everything a graphic designer, sign designer needs.

      I think of it as the swiss army knife of Graphic Design. You can replace many other Adobe programs with just this one graphics suite. But you will not go ‘deeper’ in each field. Each Adobe program that Corel can compete with are much more ‘complete’ but also much more complex. It’s practically impossible to learn, even just the basics , as self-taught. Corel’s terms are easier to understand and their behavior when trying the computer designing for the first time at all.

      Shamanu, you mention clients don’t care if work is made from any software available. It depends on the clients. From a freelance designer’s point of view, it’s very different and I might ad problematic. The clients hiring freelance designers must consider the software used. If, for any reason, they need slight changes to be done, unsatisfying service from the designer or any reason whatsoever, they have to rely on the easiest way to have changes done to their files/projects. That’s where Corel gets a kick right in the gut!

      I’ve lost many job and career opportunities due to the fact that I only use CorelDRAW. Many clients or employers have sadly refused my candidacy for that one and only reason.

      On the upside though, since Corel isn’t so wide spread, it has protected me too. Funny situation that has happened more than once! Unloyal clients with the purpose of attempting to not pay me, trying to get print jobs done (with low resolution preview files that printers don’t agree to with) have no choice but to ask for native files. So I send them CDR files. They have again, another trap that they head right into. They end up paying me for either the high resolution PDF production files or converted to Adobe files.

  • Bill Kennedy

    Nick, I’ve been printing decals for model railroading on an HP laser printer from Inkscape on my PC. I’ve had much success in modifying fonts to match the real railroads with Inkscape. However, I’m having problems with the toner chipping, especially black, upon model application. I’ve used about every paper type setting and printer density setting without solution. I’ve spoken to a decal professional who said my problem was printing with Inkscape. He uses Corel Draw. He didn’t say it had anything to do with the RGB/CMYK issue but stated that printing was just not Inkscape’s strong suit. I feel it has more to do with the HP settings selections. I’ve spoken with HP and the person that I spoke with didn’t even know what a decal was! Plesase advise. Thank you.

  • Jake

    Coreldraw is a User and Machine plug-ins Friendly. It can run most complicated machines than other designing software. It can run, Laser Cutter and engraver, CNC Machines, Cutter Plotter, and more. So Learning it is not only for Sign Companies, but Learning it is an enterprise 🙂

    • Nick Saporito

      Thank you, I’ll have to check that out. I looked into that extension a few years ago and it didn’t work, but I’ll see if anything has changed.

Comments are closed.